Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: Major angle shot at EPT Monte Carlo by eventual winner Aleksandr Shevliakov?

  1. #1
    Owner Dan Druff's Avatar
    Reputation
    10875
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    57,783
    Blog Entries
    2
    Load Metric
    102037274

    Major angle shot at EPT Monte Carlo by eventual winner Aleksandr Shevliakov?

    First, watch the below video (the bottom one):

    https://twitter.com/PokerStarsLIVE/status/1921172688510333174

    Cliffs: With 6 left in an event with 1 million euro up top, Aleksandr Shevliakov had AK suited in the SB. Jamil Wakil raised it to 270k under the gun with QJ suited (BB was 120k), and it folded to Shevliakov. At that point, Shevliakov did a "raise" to 360k, which was enough to be a forced raise (as it was more than half of the previous raise amount of 150k), but not enough to be a full 3-bet. Shevliakov claimed that he didn't see the UTG raise from Wakil, and thought he was just open raising the BB from his SB. Floor (correctly) ruled it a min-raise to 420k. Wakil, believing that Shevliakov had a very wide range of hands in a SB/BB confrontation, shoved, got snap-called, and busted.

    After busting, another player told Wakil that Shevliakov had done this before, and Wakil came to strongly suspect that the "I didn't see you raise" routine was an angle shot, intending to induce an all-in shove.



    Wakil later made this statement on X:

    https://twitter.com/JamWakil/status/1921662330183577677

    I’ve been receiving a lot of messages about the situation with Aleksandr Shevliakov, leading to my 6th place finish in the EPT Monte Carlo Main Event yesterday, so I’ve made some comments below to address it. The reason for this post is strictly because I believe that it is important to protect the game that we all love, and to point out the players who may willingly attempt to compromise the integrity of the incredible game of poker.

    To start, I want to commend the commentary team of @J_Hartigan @Stapes @GriffinBenger for handling the situation at the table with clarity and professionalism, keeping the focus on the gameplay while responsibly addressing what occurred.

    Early in the stream, this player repeatedly declined to place both of his cards in the RFID card reader box unless the hand went to a flop. Despite multiple polite requests from the dealer, this continued. I raised the issue because the rest of the table was being asked to reveal both cards, and he was the only one not doing so. Another player also joined in, and the floor was called. Aleksandr stated his reasoning was concern over delayed stream information being shared from the rail - a somewhat fair concern - but nonetheless, consistency in rule enforcement matters. After some back and forth, the floor ended up making a new ruling at the time, that phones were no longer allowed on the rail for the FT.

    Moving on to the bust out hand - I am extremely confident that this was an angle that was done deliberately by this player. Prior to this taking place, the respect that I had for Aleksandr made me truly believe that he would not pull a move like this on such a big/prestigious stage, with hundreds of thousands of viewers, knowing that the entire FT is being recorded and that it would be extremely easy to look back at the stream and see exactly where he was looking, having no way of lying about not seeing me act. Unfortunately, I have since learned that just because I hold myself to the highest of ethical and moral standards, and have tremendous respect for my opponents and for the game of poker, does not necessarily mean that everyone else feels or acts the same way.

    Aside from the very clear photo below where he can be seen staring directly at me as I am waiting to act, here are the three primary reasons (in no particular order) that I believe this was a deliberate angle:

    1) I used up almost my entire shot clock (~15 seconds) before opening, and verbally announcing my raise and size. The dealer then also verbally announced my raise and size prior to the action coming to him.

    2) This was the first time at this FT (of 6) where he verbally announced any raise or bet size in any hand that he was involved in.

    3) As soon as the all in was taking place, Boris Angelov called him out for “fake misclicking” and then let us know that he did the exact same thing to his friend with 20 players left in this same event.

    Oftentimes, if something like this is an honest mistake, you will see a person looking down on their phone and genuinely not paying attention. This has happened to most people at some point playing live poker. However, as we are not allowed electronic devices at the FT, he had no other distractions in sight, outside of the waitress who brought him his drink prior to the hand beginning, but she was out of the picture at this point.

    For those who will say, “but you tried to take advantage of his mistake”: as @GriffinBenger said on the stream, the hand completely changes when this happens and the options come down to which strategic route I want to take, without being deceptive or trying to trick my opponent. There is a very big difference between adapting to an opponent’s mistake, and actively creating confusion to gain an edge while hiding your intent.

    With all of this being said, I take full accountability for believing that he was not angling and for my decision to go all in. If I thought that the probability of him deliberately angling was higher, I most likely would’ve chosen to continue in this hand by calling. At the end of the day, what he did is within the rules of the game, and while most people, including myself, view this as an unethical act to gain an unfair advantage, he did not do something that is outside of the current set of rules and it can be fairly argued that he outsmarted me in this situation. Regardless, if he was willing to stop play to demand stricter fairness around phones on the rail, then he should be held to that same standard when it comes to protecting the integrity of the game itself.

    Despite the situation that took place, I’d still like to congratulate Aleksandr on his victory, and to the rest of the players for a great final table performance. Sincere thanks to all of the hardworking @PokerStarsLIVE staff for running a world-class event as always, and for @PokerNews on their coverage of the event. Looking forward to being back next year and going for an even deeper run. - JW
    I'll put Aleksandr Shevliakov's response in the next post.

  2. #2
    Owner Dan Druff's Avatar
    Reputation
    10875
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    57,783
    Blog Entries
    2
    Load Metric
    102037274
    https://twitter.com/AlexShevliakov/status/1922151701043155369


    Hi, my name is Alexander Shevliakov, and this is my message regarding the AKs hand against Jamil Wakil.

    I held off posting this immediately because I wanted to speak privately with Jamil first and give him the full version. Now that I’ve done that, I’m sharing it publicly so people can hear the other side.

    I’ve already been labeled as an angle shooter, even though no one outside of the Russian-speaking poker community knows my full version of the events. I’d gladly give an interview, but my level of English likely wouldn’t allow me to express my position properly.

    Let me start from the end of Day 4 of the Main Event. We were at the same table with Boris Angelov and Stoyan Obreshkov. Blinds were 15k/30k. I opened the button to 60k with K8s. Stoyan 3-bet from the small blind to 185k. We had around 50bb stacks. His sizing looked small to me, and I was deciding between a 4-bet and a call, eventually leaning toward the call. I put my chips out, and — shit — the dealer tells me to add another 100k. “How the hell did I mess this up?” flashes through my mind. A rookie mistake.

    Flop comes K64 with no flush draw. I may be wrong, but I think Stoyan bet something like 100k — I call. Pot is about 730k.
    Turn is another king. I look at the board — as I often do during hands — and Stoyan says “four seventy-five.” With my hand, it feels like there’s no real option but to call. Sure, there’s a case for raising, but the sizing is large and SPR is low. I figure we’ll get it in on the river anyway. I remove a chip from a tower of 20 x 25k chips and push it forward. Then the dealer says it’s an invalid raise. “Damn,” I think — “you’ve messed up again in the same hand.”

    Turns out, Stoyan had said and bet 275k, not 475k.
    Please note: two seventy-five and four seventy-five can sound very similar for a non-native speaker, especially after playing 8–12 hours a day for 5 days straight.
    They call the floor, explain the raise is invalid, and my action is ruled a call.

    River is a low paired card — a 4 or 6. Stoyan checks, I jam around SPR 1. He folds, saying that if my turn action was a trick, he should quit poker. He also said that if I was calling 475k, it’s clear he had a strong range.
    Later on Day 5, we discussed the hand — he told me his actual holding and agreed the hand would’ve ended the same way anyway.

    I don’t think Boris was fully paying attention to this hand, but it’s likely he saw the sizing confusion or at least noticed something odd.
    To me, it’s obvious this situation is completely different from the AKs hand on the final table.

    Fast forward to Day 5. Boris and Mariusz were constantly communicating with their rail during the day, getting delayed stream information — around 30 minutes behind — without leaving the table. Phones and smartwatches were technically banned.
    I didn’t like the situation — it hurt my EV and the EV of everyone else who didn’t have people feeding them stream data — but it wasn’t against the rules, so I didn’t complain.

    Day 6. At the start of the day, I started thinking about ways to hide my cards from the stream to prevent that kind of information from being relayed. I decided not to show one card.
    The dealer asked me several times to place the cards properly, and I said I didn’t want to — it wasn’t against the rules.
    Around that time, Jamil started objecting, saying I was hiding information and gaining an edge. I told him I would explain my reasoning later — I genuinely didn’t understand why he, who had no one feeding him stream info, was the one objecting.

    Then Kokhestani joined in, saying if I don’t show, he won’t either. At that point, the floor came over and made what I believe was a perfect decision — devices were banned from the rail. From that moment, players could only get stream info during breaks — once every two hours. Perfectly fair.

    I was fully satisfied and immediately began placing the cards correctly.
    Still, I was nervous — I had to explain my position to the tournament director (in bad English), had just clashed with the whole table, and kept replaying the situation in my head.

    That happened around minute 41 of the stream.
    At minute 43, I check-folded pocket kings (a mistake), with more emotion on my face than when I later won the final hand — a sign that I was clearly not in the best mental state.
    At minute 45, I folded 53s and started talking to the waitress — she brought me tea, but I had no cash (our phones were taken). She spoke even worse English than I did. Kokhestani, seeing I was stuck, paid for my tea — that’s on video.

    I sat there drinking tea, thinking about where to find €10 to pay him back, whether I misplayed the KK hand, whether the rail situation was fair, how I’d already been playing for 7 straight days, and oh yeah — I’m at the final table of the EPT Main Event and the money is massive.

    Next hand — the AKs hand.
    Jamil was sitting on the far end of the table. Bright lights were in my face (should’ve brought sunglasses). I finally had my tea. Enrico folded. Mariusz folded. Boris folded. I looked at my cards — AKs — decided to open. I looked at the timer (I usually avoid snap-decisions to not give away timing tells). I grabbed chips and put them out. I announced the raise.
    About the verbal announcement — I haven’t reviewed the entire video, but I believe I did this in other hands as well. If this was the first time, I don’t know why I did it — maybe it’s a pattern, maybe a tell. Maybe it’s worth analyzing the previous day for comparison.

    Then the dealer told me the sizing was wrong and pointed to Jamil’s raise.
    It was only at that moment that I realized Jamil had already raised. I hadn’t seen it or processed it — I was focused on my action, my tea, the timer, and avoiding mistakes.
    I didn’t understand what the ruling would be — raise or call — but I immediately realized how bad this would look if ruled a raise.

    I had no idea what to do.
    And frankly, none of the possible options made any sense:

    Folding would look absurd and be +EV suicide

    Asking for a re-deal would be ridiculous and not allowed

    Asking Jamil to fold to a 3-bet? Nonsense
    So I sat there, drank tea, and waited for the situation to resolve.

    Jamil made a correct shove but ran into the top of my range. Before revealing my hand, I said “this wasn’t angle shooting” and apologized.

    Boris made a comment — half-joking or not — that “this is starting to look like a pattern,” referring to Day 4.
    Jamil busted while hearing that. I stood up and tried to apologize and shake hands — he refused. I understand. From his side, with the info he had, it looked dirty.

    One more thing about the angle shooting accusation in the AKs spot —
    If I were trying to angle shoot, the simpler and more effective way would’ve been to just say “raise” and put the chips out.
    Given everything that had happened leading up to that moment, and the stress I was under, it wasn’t even obvious to me within 10 seconds whether 360k would be ruled a raise or a call.

    From my side — it was a stupid, unlucky sequence of events and inattentiveness brought on by cumulative EPT stress and the stress of that morning. And now I’ve been labeled an angle shooter.

    I’m nearly unknown in the English-speaking poker world.
    But in the Russian-speaking community, I’ve had countless friends and colleagues — in both cash games and MTTs.
    My reputation has always been clean — no debts, no broken deals, no history of angle shooting.

    Jamil let me know that he won’t be commenting on this, and I fully respect that.
    For my part, I’m also not planning to continue engaging in this discussion — unless someone directly involved (like Stoyan) publicly disputes key facts.
    Otherwise, this is the full story as I experienced it.

    That’s how it really happened — no angles, no tricks, just an unfortunate sequence in a high-pressure spot.
    Thanks for taking the time to read it.
    Aleksandr Shevliakov

  3. #3
    Owner Dan Druff's Avatar
    Reputation
    10875
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    57,783
    Blog Entries
    2
    Load Metric
    102037274
    The community is split on this one.

    About half the people responding to Shevilakov believe him, and the other half think he's full of shit.

    There's also a small contingent of people who believe that BOTH guys were shitty -- Shevliakov for pulling the initial angle, and Wakil for trying his own angle to take advantage of what he thought was the other player's confusion/mistake.

    Anyway, upon thinking about it, here are the points in favor and against this being an angle shot....


    Points in FAVOR of it being an angle-shot:

    - It was only 6-handed, and if you go to the 40 second mark on the video, it does kind of appear Shevliakov is looking at Wakil (meaning he knew there was a raise).

    - Another player at the table insisted that Shevliakov pulled something similar in a recent tournament.

    - As Wakil pointed out, this was the only time at the final table where Shevliakov announced the amount he was raising, rather than just putting chips out.

    - Shevliakov's explanation is overly long and seems to be playing up how confused and tired he was at both this and the other tournament. Why is he always so fatigued, and how does he keep doing well despite that?

    - Shevliakov shouldn't have had a lot of distractions, given that phones were not allowed at the table at this point.


    Points AGAINST it being an angle-shot:

    - This sort of mistake happens frequently in tournaments. In fact, I've had it occur a number of times myself.

    - AK suited isn't the best spot to pull this, because it's not a huge favorite against any hand not holding an A or K, and is in fact a dog against a pocket pair. It's not like he pulled this with KK or AA.

    - The "other tournament" situation, as described by Shevliakov, is somewhat different, and more involved him twice putting out the wrong amounts to call, rather than feigning a wide range preflop.



    What is my guess? It's actually close. The statement by Shevliakov seems kinda sincere, but it also overly rambles about nonsense like how he'd pay for a 10-euro tea he ordered (lol), and how that was stressing him out so much. Part of me believes it, and part of me also thinks the guy reverse engineered the story from what everyone saw (such as him holding the tea), and crafted something overly detailed and thus believable. In fact, I do the same thing when trying to talk my way out of a ticket when pulled over -- trying to cite "confusion" as the reason I either didn't notice my speed or made an illegal turn, and I try to cite real-life things happening (such as a lot of trucks on the road, or hard-to-see signs) to explain it. In reality, I was knowingly speeding and/or turning illegally.

    Was he really paying that little attention with 6 people left, and no phone to take away his attention? That's a bit hard to swallow.

    Still, 6-handed at EPT Monte Carlo for a million is a big spot, especially knowing it's being televised. People sometimes do stupid things under pressure, and it's possible that Shevliakov was just having an off moment, and truly didn't see the UTG raise. And as stated above, AK-suited is anything but a lock hand all-in, as it's not crushing anything except hands with an ace or king.

    If I had to guess,though, I'd say Shevliakov was angle shooting here. Where there's smoke, there's usually fire, and I'm finding it hard to believe that this experienced pro keeps mis-sizing his bets and getting tired/confused so often. While the situation in the other event wasn't identical, indeed once again he got "confused" to his own benefit.

    The stack sizes are important here. Wakil had about 3.9m coming in (32.5bb), and Shevliakov had about 7m. Wakil opened to a little over 2 bb, and if Shevliakov 3-bets to something like 7bb, and gets a call, then they go into the flop with a 15bb pot, and about 27bb effective stacks. This makes it very tough for Shevliakov to play out of position, as any reasonable flop bet starts to pot-commit himself, yet he's out of position. What if he bets brick flop and gets called? Then what, unless an A/K hits the turn?

    Therefore, rather than risk playing this difficult stack size out of position, he might have preferred to angle Wakil to get it in pre with a likely inferior (though possibly not vastly inferior) hand, and could also have the confidence that he'd still be left with 3m if he got it in and lost.

    What do you guys think?

  4. #4
    Gold
    Reputation
    444
    Join Date
    Apr 2021
    Posts
    1,925
    Load Metric
    102037274
    I don't think I'd have an issue with it if I were on the other end of this hand. If its within the rules or not cheating then its fair game. The guy shoving with QJ has himself to blame for the shove and loss. You can say the "angle shot" induced the shove but its still a bad decision without even so much as a pair.

  5. #5
    Bronze
    Reputation
    40
    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Posts
    146
    Load Metric
    102037274
    The real "pro" angle shoot here would have been to put out just enough chips for it to be a raise, then announce call knowing you would be forced to raise. Then you argue about how you're just trying to call still knowing they will make you raise. Anyone really trying to angle I think would have gone about it this way in my eyes. There's a time in this games history where this would have been considered gamesmanship. While I'm not sure I agree, the effect it probably had on this hand was minor. I'm also self aware enough to know that if I was the one setting there it happened to I'd probably be pissed off, but from the floor perspective none of the talk really matters.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 2 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 2 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. Angle shot? Not in my opinion.
    By JohnCommode in forum Scams, Scandals, and Shadiness
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 05-31-2023, 02:28 PM
  2. Monte Carlo Poker Room to Close 4/25/17
    By Shizzmoney in forum Casinos & Las Vegas
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 05-04-2017, 07:53 AM
  3. Monte Carlo Las Vegas to split into two resorts
    By LegallyNonBindingPosts in forum Casinos & Las Vegas
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 06-04-2016, 06:01 AM
  4. Brutal Angle Shot
    By SpewArtist in forum Scams, Scandals, and Shadiness
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 09-02-2013, 07:19 AM
  5. geezer collusion? and Monte Carlo trip report...
    By Texter in forum Flying Stupidity
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 07-04-2013, 02:33 PM